Best Used Tesla Model Y Deals

We're tracking 158 used tesla model y listings across the country, ranked by the PriceTalon Score (real value — reliability-adjusted life left per dollar). Median price is $32,730, with deals starting around $18,896. The best-value cars are first.

47USED SCORE

$28,989

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

19,516 mi · Tampa, FL · Dealer Direct

⚖

46USED SCORE

$24,600

2020 Tesla Model Y Used

48,615 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo

⚖

46USED SCORE

$27,800

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

37,305 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo

⚖

46USED SCORE

$27,300

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

37,688 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo

⚖

45USED SCORE

$24,800

2020 Tesla Model Y Used

52,413 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo

⚖

44USED SCORE 🔻 $1,591 (5%)

$28,442$30,033

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

36,119 mi · Dallas, TX · Dealer Direct

⚖

44USED SCORE

$26,100

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

66,696 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo

⚖

44USED SCORE

$30,100

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

42,957 mi · Renton, WA · MarketCheck

⚖

43USED SCORE 🔻 $325 (1%)

$29,927$30,252

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

32,505 mi · Dallas, TX · Dealer Direct

⚖

43USED SCORE

$33,225

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

17,050 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo

⚖

43USED SCORE

$34,200

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

16,947 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo

⚖

43USED SCORE

$33,950

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

16,520 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo

⚖

43USED SCORE

$28,995

2020 Tesla Model Y Used

35,685 mi · Chicago, IL · MarketCheck

⚖

43USED SCORE

$28,999

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

39,448 mi · Woodstock, GA · MarketCheck

⚖

43USED SCORE

$28,999

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

45,547 mi · Trooper, PA · MarketCheck

⚖

43USED SCORE

$27,999

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

51,040 mi · Trooper, PA · MarketCheck

⚖

43USED SCORE

$29,999

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

37,398 mi · Trooper, PA · MarketCheck

⚖

43USED SCORE

$29,862

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

42,953 mi · Los Angeles, CA · MarketCheck

⚖

43USED SCORE

$30,000

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

41,413 mi · Jacksonville, FL · MarketCheck

⚖

42USED SCORE

$30,632

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

32,346 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo

⚖

42USED SCORE

$30,200

2020 Tesla Model Y Used

36,067 mi · Dallas, TX · MarketCheck

⚖

42USED SCORE

$30,990

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

32,626 mi · Haines City, FL · MarketCheck

⚖

42USED SCORE

$30,995

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

40,358 mi · Wall Township, NJ · MarketCheck

⚖

41USED SCORE

$27,985

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

59,801 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo

⚖

41USED SCORE

$28,083

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

60,629 mi · Lake Elsinore, CA · MarketCheck

⚖

41USED SCORE

$30,200

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

49,872 mi · Dallas, TX · MarketCheck

⚖

41USED SCORE

$30,200

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

49,777 mi · Tucson, AZ · MarketCheck

⚖

41USED SCORE

$30,999

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

56,168 mi · Trooper, PA · MarketCheck

⚖

41USED SCORE

$35,995

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

21,341 mi · Huntington, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

40USED SCORE 🔻 $1,634 (5%)

$31,990$33,624

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

42,606 mi · Dallas, TX · Dealer Direct

⚖

40USED SCORE

$40,950

2025 Tesla Model Y Used

3,814 mi · Las Vegas, NV · DealerFire

⚖

40USED SCORE

$29,912

2020 Tesla Model Y Used

45,695 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo

⚖

40USED SCORE 🔻 $1,000 (3%)

$35,995$36,995

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

22,606 mi · AutoRevo

⚖

40USED SCORE

$37,995

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

10,241 mi · AutoRevo

⚖

40USED SCORE

$30,000

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

54,073 mi · Pleasant Grove, UT · MarketCheck

⚖

40USED SCORE

$30,590

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

50,837 mi · Fountain, CO · MarketCheck

⚖

📈 See Tesla Model Y price trends →

← All car deals by make